So officially, now, the College Football Playoff Bought And Paid For By ESPN is a 24-team extravaganza, which I guess means SEC Inc. and Big Ten Inc. get what they wanted: A playoff that includes every SEC and Big Ten school with a winning record.
OK. So maybe not.
OK, so maybe a 6-6 Mississippi State doesn't get in, or a 7-5 Arkansas, or the football colossus that is, say, a 5-7 Rutgers. But if the goal of ESPN, which sort of owns SEC Inc., was to get more of "its" schools into the Big Payday, consider it mission accomplished for all parties concerned.
ESPN gets the expanded CFP, and lame-o SEC or Big Ten schools will get to be the Mercer or Howard or Maryland-Baltimore County of the CFP — only with zero chance to pull off one of those 16-over-1s or 15-over-2s that put the Madness in March Madness.
Football, alas, is not basketball. A .500 Maryland team is not taking out, say, 9-3 Alabama in the first round. You can pencil in the 42-17 final and just move on.
This is not to say a 24-team playoff does not have its upside. Included in the package are nine-game conference schedules for the big boys, which eliminates a lot of the Puffed Rice U.'s and Lemon Meringue Techs on Indiana's, er, Power 4 teams' schedules. That's because in a 24-team field, a Power 4 can risk an early loss or two by scheduling other Power 4s and still get in -- whether it deserves to or not.
Some folks think this will force Notre Dame, finally, to join a conference, because if everyone's playing nine conference games there won't be a lot of dates left for independents like ND. But this presumes ND is still a football independent, which it isn't, really. Half its games already are against ACC opponents, of which the Irish are official members in everything but football; if they lose dates because of expanded conference skeddys, they can always fill in with a North Carolina State or Virginia or some other ACC school it doesn't already play.
No, the schools that really get rogered in all this are the Group of Six schools, which in the expanded structure get tossed a crumb or two from the Power 4 tables. There's a reason your Woffords and Ball States and Kenesaw States volunteer to get ball-peened by Georgia or Ohio State or Indiana every year; it's because they need the cash and those games are a a healthy payout. A couple million in guarantee dough plumps up cash-strapped small school athletic budgets in fine style.
Now, the big shooters don't need to schedule cupcake guarantee games anymore -- and with expanded conference slates and a mandated number of Power 4 games, they don't have room for them in any case. So buh-bye, money train.
(Also, buh-bye conference title games. No loss. They were never anything more than cash grabs for the conferences anyway. Same goes for conference tournaments in basketball, for that matter. As John Wooden once told me.)
What else?
Well, with another round or two added to the CFP festivities -- and with all the extra revenue those rounds will bring in -- what happens to the presumption that the kids upon whose backs that extra revenue will be made are, you know, actual college students?
Well, sorry, folks, but that went out with raccoon coats, sis-boom-bah and the groves of academe. It was gone the first time some stud transferred from Whatsamatta U. to Whatsittoya U. for a million-dollar bump in NIL green. And the first time the same stud transferred from Whatsittoya U. to Getthefuggouttahere U., and then to Whatareyoulookinat U.
Now?
Now, in exchange for their NIL paychecks, the scholars who play for the two teams that wind up in the CFP title game will be playing a schedule as long as the NFL grind. Indiana, for instance, went 16-0 last season to win the national championship. Now you're adding another game or two? For, in many cases, not grown men but 19, 20-year-old kids?
The season, for the two best teams, will now run from Labor Day weekend to the middle of January with scarcely a break. And, yeah, the players get paid now, and, yeah, that essentially makes them professionals, but where does the "college" in college football come in anymore?
Might as well call it what it is now: The National (College) Football League. A wholly owned subsidiary of ESPN, Fox, NBC, ABC and CBS.
Shame. I kinda liked my raccoon coat.